Dan Coughlin: Don’t call Champ Car joining IRL a merger, call it a surrender
Print this story
Read comments and discuss this story
It’s stretching a point to call it a merger of the Indy Racing League and Champ Car after a bitter 15-year schism that almost put open-wheel racing in America out of business. Actually, Champ Car surrendered to IRL founder Tony George. Only a handful of Champ Car races will be incorporated into the IRL schedule and Cleveland isn’t one of them. The IRL already had a race scheduled for the same weekend.
It’s possible that Cleveland could be added to the IRL schedule in the future, although Cleveland doesn’t fit the IRL format, which is going in circles and bouncing off walls. After all, the Indy Racing League’s name is derived from Indianapolis 500. But Cleveland race promoter Mike Lanigan of Chicago seems to have an amicable relationship with George, the most powerful man in American racing outside of NASCAR, which keeps the embers of hope smoldering.
Champ Car specialized in twisting road races, such as the Cleveland Grand Prix at Burke Lakefront Airport. Other races were held on city streets, much like Formula I, and ultimately the concept failed in this country. The majority of the drivers were foreigners and when they became stars, such as the Frenchman Sebastien Bourdais most recently, they moved up to Formula I. Champ Car was a minor league, a development series for Formula I. (Similarly, the IRL could be perceived as a development league for NASCAR.)
Ironically, from a racing purist’s pespective, the airport layout in Cleveland was the best in all of road racing, here or abroad. From high in the bleachers you could see the entire 12-turn course, which is not possible at any Formula I race. Serious fans could time the laps and determine who was catching the leader or who was falling back.
But there were not enough dedicated fans and not enough dedicated sponsors. Most people wanted to see fiery crashes and cars upside down, and if you don’t give the customers what they want, you are doomed to go out of business. Somehow the Cleveland Grand Prix survived for 26 years and I was there for all of them.
And now I find myself ambivalent, which is odd for this reason. I always felt a parental relationship with the race because I broke the story of its birth. While covering the 1981 Indianapolis 500, I stumbled upon the revelation that an Indy-car race would be held in Cleveland the next year.
Chris Economaki, an auto racing commentator for ABC Sports, made an off-hand comment when our paths crossed at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway the day before the 500.
“By the way,” he said, “I’m going to be in your town next year for the race at the airport.”
“What??!!”
I spent the rest of the day piecing together enough of a story to strip across the top of Page 1 on Sunday morning. It sounded like the fulfillment of a fantasy — racing on the lakefront with yachts and sailboats in the background. It was Monte Carlo in the Rust Belt and it was exhilarating.
Several years earlier a Cleveland ad agency man named Saul Isler and I shared a vision for a race through the city streets. In our dream we had cars racing through the Innerbelt, Public Square and downtown streets. I wrote a column about it, even though it seemed outlandish. How could anyone be serious?
But I had a history with Formula I racing. It was brief but unforgettable. In 1967 I covered the Grand Prix of Monaco, the race that winds through the streets of Monte Carlo and past the harbor crowded with exotic yachts.
The night before the race, I sat at the bar of the Hotel de Paris while about 25 feet away race car legend Graham Hill sat drinking with Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton. I can’t tell you how beautiful Elizabeth looked that night 41 years ago. Think of the most lovely object you’ve ever seen and multiply it by a thousand.
The next day I was almost as close to the podium where Princess Grace and Prince Ranier presented the trophy to race winner Denis Hulme of New Zealand, who went on to win the world championship that year. Princess Grace! Multiply it by a million.
To this day, former sportswriter Chuck Webster, now a lawyer, marvels at such an assignment.
“Whom were you blackmailing?” he once asked.
I never figured it out, either.
There is always a dark side to auto racing, however. Lorenzo Bandini, the 32-year-old star of the Ferrari racing team, crashed and was killed. His car caught fire and he was trapped underneath it. He burned to death before safety crews could get to him. Bandini was in second place late in the race and was driving like a fiend to catch Hulme when he lost control.
There you have the mystique of Formula I — movie stars, royalty and tragedy.
I tasted it once in real life. After that it became a recurrent dream, like “Groundhog Day.” I never woke up with Elizabeth Taylor and Princess Grace. For 26 years I woke up with Sonny and Cher.
Dan Coughlin is a sports columnist for The Chronicle-Telegram and a sportscaster for Fox 8. Contact him at ctsports@chroniclet.com.
Print this story
Report an innappropriate comment
In order to comment, you must agree to our user agreement
and discussion guidelines.
You must be registered and logged in to post a comment. If you aren't already registered,
click here.
If you are registered, click here to log in.
Need help? Email Us.

Lorain/Elyria, OH


Going around circles and bouncing off walls? Most contemporary oval track races feature great racing in plain view of the fans at beautiful facilities.
Most events at temporary courses could easily be characterized as bouncing off man-hole covers and concrete barriers out of the view of 85% of the fans at any given time. The ones that survive are largely big parties (Long Beach) and corporate outings (Belle Isle).
Burke is a notable exception. It’s the only temporary course I would visit and I do hope it gets added to the 2009 schedule.
But remember it could have and should have been on the sked now. The IRL tried to go there and its overtures were rejected by short-sighted Clevelanders who dismissed it as an inferior product to the already dying CART/CC bunch who could never seem to figure out how to get through turn 1 on the first lap.
I hope that Cleveland makes the cut next year. Assuming, of course, that IndyCars are welcomed by the beautiful city by the lake and not met with atitudes like yours.
(Report comment)
Michal, Cleveland never made it into the IRL schedule because the FAA would have to approve the changes needed to turn it into an oval track, and the city wasn’t willing to put forth the money to make such changes, anyway. Indeed, the fans were opposed to it. Not simply because IRL is an inferior product(while that’s up for debate since about 2005 or so, it was most DEFINITELY the inferior product in 1999, when the IRL tried to schedule their race there - CART didn’t start its downhill spiral until 2001), but because they refused to tolerate the idea of changing what is quite simply the greatest road course on Earth.
As a (vintage formula) racer, I can say that I’m always consistently bored by ovals. NASCAR is occasionally entertaining due to the full-contact nature of the racing, but even it struggles most of the time. But in my experience ovals longer than a mile around are just too easy to be entertaining. It seems many racing fans agree with this opinion, as well. IRL struggled to fill the seats at most of their oval venues. Champ Car had issues with TV coverage, but almost all of their races had full grandstands. Modern racing fans just aren’t interested in ovals when it comes to open-wheels. Tony George is starting to realize this: Its why he’s offered Champ Car so much to “surrender.” He needs their venues and he knows it.
Champ Car does seem to be giving up a lot right now, but by 2010 when we have that 50/50 oval/road course mix that TG has promised and most of those road courses are former Champ Car venues we’ll realize that yes, this truly IS a merger.
Lets face it, as superior as it is on road courses the Panoz DP-01 was not built for ovals. A unified series couldn’t feasibly use it until it had been adapted. The Dallara was ready to go on both and was perfectly positioned to fill in the gap until the new IRL car comes out in 2010. ‘08 and ‘09 are just preparation and adjustment to make things as good as they can be for ‘10.
Here’s one Champ Car fan who’s looking forward to seeing things develop. And being only an hour from Cleveland, I hope Cleveland will be on the schedule again in ‘09.
(Report comment)