May 25, 2016


Deal means Nancy Smith will remain free

Nancy Smith in court today. (CT photo by Bruce Bishop.)

Nancy Smith in court today. (CT photo by Bruce Bishop.)

ELYRIA — Nancy Smith will not return to prison under a sentencing agreement with prosecutors approved today.



Smith wiped tears from her eyes as the hearing concluded in a courtroom packed with her supporters.

Visiting Judge Virgil Sinclair agreed to sentence Smith to 12 years in prison in the controversial Head Start child molestation case.

The original sentence imposed on Smith was 30-to-90 years in prison and she had already served roughly 15 years in prison. Sinclair reduced the original rape charges Smith was convicted of to gross sexual imposition.

The terms of the agreement bar Smith, who has long maintained her innocence, from filing a wrongful imprisonment lawsuit. A motion for a new trial Smith’s lawyers had filed was dismissed under the agreement.

Smith’s lawyers said their client wanted to put the fear of being returned to prison behind her.

Smith was freed in 2009 by Lorain County Common Pleas Judge James Burge because of a technical flaw in the 1994 sentencing entry that ordered her to prison. Burge freed her codefendant Joseph Allen, that same year and later acquitted both after reviewing the evidence in the case.

He said at the time that he had no confidence the guilty verdicts were correct. The Ohio Supreme Court ruled in 2011 that Burge had overstepped his authority.

Smith and Allen, who wasn’t in court today, remained free after that and both have asked the Ohio Parole Board to recommend that Ohio Gov. John Kasich grant them executive clemency. Burge appeared before the Parole Board in January at a hearing for Smith and urged them to back her clemency bid.

Burge later removed himself from the case and Sinclair was appointed to replace him. Lawyers for both Smith and Allen have asked Sinclair to order new trials based on what they contend is newly discovered evidence of botched interviews of the 4- and 5-year-olds who claimed they were molested by the pair.

Read Wednesday’s Chronicle for more on this story.

About Brad Dicken

Brad Dicken is the senior writer for the Chronicle-Telegram. He covers courts and county government, and has been with the Chronicle since 2001. He can be reached at 329-7147 or Follow him on Twitter.