November 21, 2014

Partly cloudy

UPDATED — Parole board says no pardon for Nancy Smith in Head Start sex case

Nancy Smith leaves court after her plea agreement. File photo/Bruce Bishop

Nancy Smith leaves court after her plea agreement.
File photo/Bruce Bishop

By a 9-2 vote, the Ohio Parole Board has recommended against a pardon for former bus driver Nancy Smith in the controversial Head Start child molestation case.

The final decision, however, belongs to Ohio Gov. John Kasich, who received the recommendation yesterday. The report was made public this morning.

The Parole Board’s recommendation comes a few months after a plea deal in the case that saw Smith plead out to reduced charges in exchange for a prison sentence that was actually less than the nearly 15 years she spent behind bars.

Smith said today that she wasn’t surprised by the Parole Board’s recommendation and vowed to continue fighting as long as it takes to clear her name.

“It’s a travesty and injustice what these people have done to me,” Smith said.

Smith and her codefendant Joseph Allen have both long denied they molested 4- and 5-year-old children on Smith’s Head Start bus route and continue to maintain their innocence. Allen is pursuing his own clemency request.

The plea agreement prevented Smith from having to register as a sex offender, but also took the possibility that her sentence could be commuted to time served off the table as an option for the Parole Board. Lorain County Prosecutor Dennis Will had backed commutation, but not a pardon.

The clemency report said that a majority of the Parole Board didn’t feel that Smith’s arguments that she was wrongfully convicted — including serious problems with how the alleged victims in the case were interviewed by police — were enough to win a favorable recommendation by the board.

They also felt that the roughly four years since Smith was freed by Lorain County Common Pleas Judge James Burge on a technicality wasn’t enough time to prove she wouldn’t reoffend.

Smith said the suggestion that she might commit a crime has no basis in reality.

“I’m not a sex offender, so they never have to worry about me reoffending because I never offended in the first place,” she said.

Two members, however, felt that “There is a strong indication that the testimony of the children/witnesses was contaminated and the applicant was weakly and/or wrongly linked to Joseph Allen, whom law enforcement believed to be a pedophile. These issues and others call into question the applicant’s involvement and conviction,” the report said.

Read Saturday’s Chronicle for more on this story.

  • Michele Monticue

    Well we know we have 9 idiots on the Ohio Parole Board…

  • Jamie Smith

    This story appears to never have a ending. Bottom line is Nancy Smith and Joseph Allen were WRONGLY accused and convicted of crimes that NEVER even happened. Its so sad that the government just won’t admit that they were wrong. These two need to be pardoned and receive a settlement for their nightmare that just keeps gong on and on. I Pray Gov John Kasich will make this right and pardon Nancy and Joseph.

  • ster85



    Nancy, don’t be afraid of evil tidings. Let your heart be firmly fixed, trusting (leaning on and being confident) in the Lord. Psalm 112:7
    All the works of (God’s) hands are (absolute) truth and justice (faithful and right) ;and His decrees and precepts are sure (fixed, established and trustworthy). Psalm 111:7.
    You WILL see your vindication, now, in the land of the living.
    The criminal justice authorities who perpetrated this injustice by allowing Satan to work through them will be held accountable, in a Godly and just way. AMEN AND HALLELUJAH!

  • David France

    OMG There is a god in heaven.