November 22, 2014


Judge accepts resignation of appointed guardian for Amish cancer patient

Nick Glunt and Loren Genson
The Chronicle-Telegram

Andy Hershberger leads family and Amish deacons to a heading at the Medina County Courthouse on Thursday afternoon. KRISTIN BAUER/CHRONICLE

Andy Hershberger leads family and Amish deacons to a heading at the Medina County Courthouse on Thursday afternoon. KRISTIN BAUER/CHRONICLE

A Medina County judge Thursday accepted the resignation of a woman appointed to make medical decisions for an 11-year-old Amish girl with cancer whose parents refused to continue chemotherapy.

The family at first accepted chemotherapy from Akron Children’s Hospital, but stopped in April because they believed the treatments were killing her.

In response, the hospital sued to have Maria Schimer, a nurse who also is an attorney, appointed a limited guardian.

Schimer was appointed in October after several months of legal battles involving the 9th District Court of Appeals.But after the family fled the country, Schimer asked in December to be allowed to relinquish her guardianship, arguing that her efforts were futile.

In court Thursday, county Probate Judge Kevin W. Dunn accepted Schimer’s resignation.

“If I thought there was any way that I could save this little girl’s life, I wouldn’t be doing this,” Schimer said through tears. “Maybe now someone else can step in who has a better rapport with the family.”

Under questioning from attorneys and the judge, Schimer said she met the child, Sarah Hershberger, only in the courtroom.

The girl’s parents, Andy and Anna Hershberger, failed to bring the girl to any of the cost-free treatments ordered under her guardianship and fled the state.

“Though they advised they sought medical treatment in another country and another state, they have provided no evidence of treatment,” Schimer told the judge. “She may appear happy and she may appear healthy, but we don’t know what’s going on inside.”

Maurice Thompson, the Hershbergers’ attorney, said the girl is recovering after seeking treatment in Canada, Mexico and Tennessee and now appears to be healthy.

Thompson said he plans to file a motion to eliminate the guardianship or to get a family member appointed as guardian.

“Either way is a result we’d be satisfied with,” said Thompson, executive director of the libertarian 1851 Center for Constitutional Law in Columbus.

Thompson said the Hershbergers haven’t ruled out chemotherapy for their daughter if her cancer gets worse.

“It’s not that they’re opposed to medical treatment,” he said. “They just felt it was killing her.”

Thompson said the family returned to their Homer Township home a few weeks ago. He said Sarah’s once-visible tumors are now gone and she has responded well to the treatments she received — including a scan performed on the girl in Mexico showing positive results.

Akron Children’s Hospital physicians testified during hearings in the summer that the girl would be dead by April or earlier if she did not get chemotherapy.

At those hearings, the girl’s parents said they were treating their daughter with “natural” medicine like herbs and vitamins.

Thompson said he’s not a doctor, but he believes the Hershbergers are working hard to get medical care for Sarah.

“They’re aggressively seeking treatment for their daughter,” Thompson said. “She’s trending upwards and she’s nowhere close to dead.”

He said the Hershbergers plan to make an appointment with a local conventional doctor now that the family has returned home.

Thompson said he will continue his defense of the Hershbergers before the Ohio Supreme Court and the 9th District Court of Appeals, where he in January filed a brief arguing that the appointment of a guardian was unconstitutional.

Thompson said it’s important to get the initial appeals court ruling overturned to protect the rights of parents to oversee medical care for their children.

“As long as that ruling is on the books, every parent has a threat of losing their child-rearing ability,” Thompson said. “It’s a dangerous precedent.”

Contact reporter Nick Glunt at (330) 721-4048 or
Contact reporter Loren Genson at (330) 721-4063 or

  • Sarah Boesger

    “As long as that ruling is on the books, every parent has a threat of
    losing their child-rearing ability,” Thompson said. “It’s a dangerous
    I think this is an inflammatory statement…what this case proves is that innocent children have the right to be medically protected from their parents’ religious zeal. This little girl is not capable of saying, ‘Yes, I am Amish and I do not want to receive chemo.’

    • tired7041

      This has nothing to do with religion, but everything to do with parental rights being further taken away. This child is shown to be improving without all the chemicals going into her tiny body. Testing has proved that her tumors have shrunk without the chemo that was making her ill. There are alternative measures out there, God made, that do heal better at times than what man has made. .

      • Jim

        If this is true, why haven’t the Herschbergers been able to provide any proof of this? I’m about as Libertarian and governtment-hands-off as anyone out there, but forcing a little girl to die from cancer because of your religious beliefs is murder.

  • Arietta Sullivan

    the way i’m reading it..they never stopped getting medical help for their daughter in spite of their religious beliefs…they sought out medical care(if it is true but nothing to proof them wrong either) for their daughter but in a few different countries&in Tennessee. i always heard ‘chemo’ made the patient even sicker&at times,ironically,made the cancer spread.i have no idea if this is true or not but if i had a diagnosis of cancer..i wouldn’t want ‘chemo’ either,not because of any religion belief just because…it’s my time to go Home. so if society wants to say my family is murdering me..go for it..what counts is how I feel and they feel&what i want..not what society wants.